Your traffic has flattened or dropped, and you’re not sure why. Maybe a competitor jumped ahead, maybe a site update broke something, or maybe your pages just aren’t as good as what now ranks. Guessing wastes time. An audit tells you what’s actually wrong.
This guide shows how to do an SEO audit for a small or mid-sized business website, step by step, using mostly free tools. You’ll finish with a clear, prioritized list of fixes instead of a 200-page report nobody reads.
Quick answer: To do an SEO audit, set a goal and collect baseline data, check Google Search Console for indexing and performance issues, crawl the site for technical errors, review speed and mobile, audit on-page SEO and content quality, check local SEO and backlinks, compare against competitors, then rank every issue by impact and effort and fix the biggest ones first.
How to Do an SEO Audit: What You Need First
You don’t need expensive software to learn how to do an SEO audit. For most small business sites, these are enough:
| Tool | Cost | What you’ll use it for |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Free | Indexing, queries, clicks, Core Web Vitals |
| Google Analytics 4 | Free | Traffic, landing pages, conversions |
| PageSpeed Insights | Free | Speed and Core Web Vitals per page |
| Screaming Frog SEO Spider | Free up to 500 URLs | Crawling for broken links, redirects, titles |
| A spreadsheet | Free | Tracking issues and priorities |
Set aside a few hours for a site with under 50 pages. Larger sites take longer.
Step 1: Set a Goal and Save Your Baseline
Start by writing down why you’re auditing. “Traffic dropped 30% since March” and “We want more quote requests from organic search” lead to different priorities. If a drop lines up with a Google core update, read how to recover from a Google core update before changing anything.
Then save your “before” numbers. Google’s Performance report in Search Console shows clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position. It shows the past three months by default, but you can change the date range. Export the top queries and pages, plus organic sessions and conversions from GA4.
Step 2: Check Indexing in Search Console
If Google hasn’t indexed a page, nothing else matters for that page.
- Open the Page indexing report and look at why pages aren’t indexed
- Check that your key service and location pages are indexed
- Look for pages marked noindex, blocked by robots.txt or duplicates without a chosen canonical
- Check the Sitemaps report shows your sitemap was read successfully
A long list of “Discovered, currently not indexed” pages is common. My guide on fixing Discovered – currently not indexed explains what to do.
Step 3: Crawl the Site for Technical Errors
Run a crawl with Screaming Frog or a similar tool. Look for:
- 404 errors and broken internal links
- Redirect chains and redirects pointing to other redirects
- Missing, duplicate or overly long title tags and meta descriptions
- Missing or multiple H1 tags
- Pages with very little content
- Mixed http and https or www and non-www versions
For a full list of what to check, use my technical SEO checklist.
Step 4: Review Speed and Mobile Experience
Test your home page and top three service pages in PageSpeed Insights, on mobile first. Then open the Core Web Vitals report in Search Console to see site-wide problems.
Also use the site on your own phone. Can you find the phone number fast? Do buttons work? Does a pop-up hide the content? Real use often reveals problems that tools miss.
Step 5: Audit On-Page SEO
For each important page, check:
- Does it target one main keyword or topic?
- Is that keyword in the title tag, H1, URL and first paragraph?
- Is the meta description written to earn the click?
- Do headings break the page into clear sections?
- Do images have descriptive alt text?
- Does the page link to related pages on your site?
A useful shortcut: in Search Console, find pages with lots of impressions but a low click-through rate. Their titles and descriptions often need rewriting.
Step 6: Judge Content Quality
This is the part most audits skip. Google’s guide to creating helpful content suggests asking questions like “Does the content provide original information, reporting, research, or analysis?” and whether it offers “substantial value when compared to other pages in search results.”
Search your main keywords and compare your page to the top three results honestly. Are they more complete, more current or more specific? Do they show real experience with photos, examples or case studies? Google’s guidance also says trust is the most important part of E-E-A-T, so check that your pages show who you are, your credentials and how to contact you.
Mark each page as keep, improve, merge or remove.
Step 7: Check Local SEO and Backlinks
For local businesses, audit your Google Business Profile: correct category, hours, photos, services and recent reviews. My local SEO checklist covers the rest.
For backlinks, Search Console’s Links report shows which sites link to you and your most linked pages. Look for broken pages that still have links pointing to them. Redirecting those to a relevant live page recovers lost value.
Step 8: Compare Against Competitors
Pick two or three competitors that outrank you for your main services. Compare:
- Which service and location pages they have that you don’t
- How detailed their pages are
- Their review count and rating on Google
- Whether they publish useful blog content
Gaps you find here often become your biggest opportunities.
Step 9: Prioritize and Build an Action Plan
An audit is only useful if it leads to action. Put every issue in your spreadsheet and score it:
| Priority | Impact | Effort | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fix now | High | Low | Noindex on a service page, broken contact form, missing redirects |
| Plan next | High | High | Rewriting thin service pages, speed improvements |
| Quick wins | Low | Low | Better title tags, missing alt text |
| Later | Low | High | Minor design tweaks, low-value pages |
Fix the “Fix now” list first, then work through the rest over the next few months. Track results against the baseline you saved in Step 1. A simple dashboard, like my Looker Studio SEO dashboard, makes that easy.
SEO Audit Checklist: One-Page Summary
Use this as a quick reference when you run your audit:
| Area | Check |
|---|---|
| Baseline | Search Console clicks, impressions and top pages exported; GA4 conversions saved |
| Indexing | Key pages indexed; no accidental noindex; sitemap read successfully |
| Technical | No broken internal links, redirect chains or duplicate site versions |
| Speed and mobile | Key pages pass Core Web Vitals; phone number and forms work on a phone |
| On-page | One topic per page; keyword in title, H1 and first paragraph; good meta descriptions |
| Content | Each key page compared with the top three results; marked keep, improve, merge or remove |
| Local | Google Business Profile complete; recent reviews; consistent details |
| Links | Broken pages with backlinks redirected |
| Competitors | Missing pages and topics listed |
| Plan | Every issue scored by impact and effort |
Common SEO Audit Mistakes
- Fixing every warning a tool reports. Many warnings don’t matter. Fix what affects your important pages first.
- Skipping the baseline. Without “before” numbers, you can’t show what the fixes changed.
- Auditing only the home page. Service pages and top landing pages usually matter more.
- Ignoring content quality. A technically perfect page still won’t rank if competing pages are more useful.
- Changing many things at once. Make changes in batches, note the date and watch the results.
- Never repeating it. Sites change, and new problems appear after updates, redesigns and new plugins.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does it take to do an SEO audit?
For a small business site with under 50 pages, a solid audit takes a few hours to a day. Larger sites, ecommerce stores or sites with many technical problems can take several days. Fixing the issues usually takes longer than finding them, so plan time for both.
How often should I do an SEO audit?
Do a full audit when you start working on SEO, after a redesign or migration and whenever traffic drops without a clear reason. Most small business sites benefit from a full audit once or twice a year, with a quick monthly check of Search Console in between.
Can I do an SEO audit myself?
Yes. Knowing how to do an SEO audit with free tools like Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and a crawler covers most issues on small sites. You may need help interpreting technical findings or fixing code-level problems like redirects, speed and structured data.
How much does a professional SEO audit cost?
Prices vary widely by site size and depth. My own SEO audit packages start at $99 for a technical audit with a prioritized fix list, $249 with up to 50 issues fixed and $449 for a complete audit with fixes and a 30-day follow-up. My guide to SEO audit service cost compares market prices.
What should an SEO audit report include?
A useful report includes your baseline numbers, a summary of the biggest problems, a prioritized list of fixes with the pages affected, and clear next steps. Skip reports with hundreds of warnings and no priorities. You should be able to act on the top five issues right away.
What are the main parts of an SEO audit?
A complete SEO audit covers indexing, technical health, speed and mobile experience, on-page SEO, content quality, local SEO, backlinks and a comparison with competitors. It ends with a prioritized action plan. For small business sites, indexing and on-page issues on key service pages usually matter most.
What is the difference between an SEO audit and a technical SEO audit?
A technical SEO audit checks whether Google can crawl, index and render your site: robots.txt, sitemaps, redirects, canonicals, speed and structured data. A full SEO audit includes that technical check and adds on-page SEO, content quality, local SEO, backlinks and competitors. Start with a full audit if you’re not sure where the problem is.
Final Thoughts
Now you know how to do an SEO audit: save your baseline, check indexing, crawl for errors, review speed, on-page SEO and content, look at local signals and competitors, then fix the highest-impact issues first. Repeat it once or twice a year and after any big site change.
If you’d rather have it done for you, my SEO audit and technical SEO service delivers a clear, prioritized fix list, or you can send me a message for a quick look at your site.





Comments
Be the first to share your thoughts or ask a question.
Leave a comment
Your email will not be published. Comments appear after review.